Shopify vs Sellfy: Which is Better For Your Online Store?

This article discusses Shopify and Sellfy, providing insights into features, pros and cons, pricing, customization, and more. Find the e-commerce platform that fits your requirements and enhances your online store, whether you’re a small business owner or an aspiring entrepreneur.

Key Takeaways

• Shopify offers smart functionality, extensive customization options, and robust support for scaling, making it ideal for businesses looking to create a sophisticated, full-featured online store.
• Sellfy is better suited for creators and small businesses looking for a straightforward, easy-to-use platform to sell digital products or merchandise, offering simple and specific digital goods tools.

Shopify vs Sellfy: A Quick Comparison

The main difference between Shopify and Sellfy lies in their primary selling approach.

Shopify supports the sale of both physical and digital products with over 100 payment options and customization options intended to help business owners build the store most suited to their needs. 

In contrast, Sellfy is more tailored for selling digital goods, subscriptions, and print-on-demand services through existing websites or social platforms, offering fewer payment methods and less customization flexibility.

Shopify vs Sellfy: Pros and Cons

Both Shopify and Sellfy have a lot of benefits and drawbacks to offer in their own right. 

Pros

• Multi-channel selling support 
• Multiple themes and design options
• Flexible pricing plans 
• Smart and advanced inventory management
• Wide range of integrations and apps available
• Various SEO and marketing features
• Over 100 payment gateways support 
• High level of scalability
• 24/7 customer support
• Advanced and detailed analytics and reports 

Cons

• Many features and dashboards can be overwhelming for a beginner
• Costly transaction fees when using third-party payment gateways 

Pros and Cons of Sellfy

Pros

• Easy to use for beginners
• Print-on-demand tools integrated into the store
• Plenty of store templates to speed up the building process 
• Easy to manage your store from a mobile app
• Specific marketing assistance to deploy e-commerce tasks

Cons

•  Free plan is limited to only ten products
• No affiliate marketing and integrations are slow

Shopify vs Sellfy: In-depth Comparison

Let’s compare Shopify and Sellfy to discover the differences between these eCommerce platforms. 

Pricing and fees 

Sellfy and Shopify both have different pricing plans to fit various business needs. But there are a few things that set them apart.

Here is a table that shows the subscription and transaction costs of both platforms, as well as any additional fees.

The Verdict

Sellfy wins this round due to its cost-effective pricing plans tailored to varying business requirements. 

However, if you want to have more pricing plan options to build your business, Shopify is more attractive. 

E-commerce features 

E-commerce businesses need different marketing factors to help their online shops grow and generate a return on investment (ROI).

Sellfy

Sellfy primarily caters to creators in selling products to build an online business.

With Sellfy, you can:

• Sell both digital and physical products
• Provide print-on-demand items for custom merchandise
• Create and sell subscription-based products or membership sites
• Sell your videos through on-demand live streaming
• Accept secure transactions via PayPal and Stripe
• Use PDF stamping to customize each customer’s product file
• Restrict product downloads through unique links to prevent unwanted sharing

Shopify

Shopify offers a more sophisticated set of tools for entrepreneurs to sell online.

With Shopify, you can:

• Sell an unlimited range of products and services, including digital items
• Utilize various sales channels to sell your products
• Manage your orders through a comprehensive system that includes inventory, shipping, and return
• Seamlessly integrate with over 100 payment gateways and accept credit card transactions
• Manage your online store remotely with the convenient Shopify mobile app.

Moreover, Shopify’s e-commerce feature allows business owners to set automated tasks: 

• Inventory management: Hide out-of-stock products and reorder items when stock levels are low.
• Customer Segmentation: Track and categorize customers based on their buying behavior.
• Fraud Detection: Identify potentially fraudulent orders instead of manually reviewing each order.

The Verdict

When it comes to e-commerce features, Shopify is ahead. Shopify offers robust multi-channel selling support and seamlessly integrates with third-party or various payment gateways to create higher ROI. 

Customization of the Storefront 

Both Shopify and Sellfy help business owners customize their stores as unique and attractive as possible. 

Sellfy 

Sellfy effortlessly creates an impressive store that uniquely stands out your brand. 

• Brand Customization: Add your logo, modify the color scheme, adjust the layout, and even change the store’s language
• Shopping Cart: Implement a shopping cart feature to allow customers to buy multiple items in one go.
• Domain Connection: Link your online store to your existing domain to boost your brand.
• Mobile Optimization: Use mobile-friendly templates and a seamless checkout experience. 

Especially, Sellfy also offers embedding tools for business owners to sell anywhere at any time:

• Embed buttons on your website
• Embed product cards to monetize your content
• Embed your entire Sellfy store to turn your website into a complete selling machine
• Create product links for social media posts
• Use YouTube cards and end-screens to bring viewers to your online shop with just one click

This built-in flexibility helps merchants grow their business and approach a wider audience of potential customers. 

Shopify 

Like Sellfy, Shopify offers an easy-to-use tool for customizing your online store:

• User-friendly, no-code store builder with a drag-and-drop interface.
• Multiple mobile-responsive themes ready to use.
• Quick checkout options to optimize conversions and close more sales.
• Personalize your storefront with customizable fonts, colors, and images. 

Moreover, Shopify also includes multiple tools to help business owners to sell their products:

• Embed buttons, products, or a complete shopping cart into your existing website 
• Synchronize your catalogs of physical and digital products with social media platforms
• Make your physical and digital products available on Google to purchase directly during their search.
• Leverage Shopify’s vast range of apps to introduce additional functions to your online store.

The Verdict 

There is a tie between Shopify and Sellfy in terms of customization. However, if you want a simple and quick storefront setup – Sellfy is the best choice. But if you need full customization to build an online store, go with Shopify. 

Payments 

When comparing Shopify and Sellfy, pricing is one of the critical factors to consider. Here’s a detailed breakdown:

Sellfy

Sellfy allows business owners to accept payments via Stripe and PayPal. They receive payment immediately after completing a transaction. 

Shopify 

Shopify supports payments through Stripe and PayPal and works with many other companies to offer over 100 different ways to pay, including using debit or credit cards.

However, all these options involve transaction fees, except for Shopify Payments. Shopify Payments offers a secure multi-currency cart without transaction fees. If your e-commerce business has unique payment methods, such as Bitcoin or other cryptocurrencies, Shopify can also accommodate those.

The Verdict 

When it comes to payments, Shopify is ahead. 

Both Shopify and Sellfy accept payments via Stripe and PayPal. However, Shopify provides a broader selection of payment options.

Marketing

Various marketing strategies are necessary to drive traffic to your store and foster robust customer relationships. Let’s discuss Sellfy and Shopify’s built-in marketing tools. 

Sellfy

Sellfy offers four main marketing features:

• Email Marketing – Construct newsletters and send product updates to customers and subscribers.
• Upsells – Boost order value by upselling products at opportune times.
• Discount Codes – Offer rewards to customers to stimulate sales and engagement.
• Tracking Pixels – Insert pixels to monitor your Facebook and Twitter ad campaigns via the built-in app marketplace.

Shopify

With Shopify’s marketing tools, you can effectively identify the right customers and market to them at the right moment. 

• Email Marketing – Utilize high-quality templates to maintain customer communication and tailor their shopping experience.
• Automation – Develop custom workflows to automate recurring marketing tasks and grow your business.
• Search Engine Optimization – Make it easy for your target audience to find your store with title tags, meta descriptions, and other SEO tools.
• Blogging – Employ content marketing to enhance your online presence and reach a broader audience.
• Customer Relationship Management – Categorize your customers based on their actions and interests.
• Google Smart Shopping – Use free listings or flexibly create a Smart Shopping campaign.
• Facebook Ads – Personalize your Facebook shop and create collections ideal for your audience.

The Verdict

Shopify surpasses Sellfy on its own, and with the Shopify app store and numerous integrations, they have significantly upped the ante. 

Shipping & Delivery 

Regularly sending quality products along with gift cards is the best way to keep your customers happy and improve customer relationships. Good shipping and delivery are vital to contribute to this success. 

Shopify  

Shopify offers the “Shopify Shipping” feature, providing customers with automatic tracking numbers for their orders on the website and printing shipping labels directly from your Shopify admin. Additionally, the Shopify app marketplace also offers a vast array of tools for shipping and inventory management tools. 

Shopify assists with shipping calculations and integrates with a broad range of shipping carriers such as UPS, FedEx, DHL, and more. It also enables centralized tracking of all your inventory, with the possibility to incorporate different sales channels in the same place.

Sellfy

Sellfy is mainly utilized by creators offering digital products, so the need for product tracking is relatively minimal. However, if merchants choose to sell merchandise or custom-printed items, they can issue tracking numbers to customers for easier management. 

By default, Sellfy sets your shipping region to “Worldwide.” However, you can change this and your shipping costs in your account settings.

The Verdict

Shopify stands out as the more robust platform for shipping and delivery. It offers various integration capabilities with a wide range of carriers. 

Reporting & Analytics

Whatever e-commerce system you’re using, it’s essential to have analytics and reporting tools to track and compare your key performance indicators (KPIs). 

Sellfy

In the Selly dashboard, you can monitor various metrics such as subscribers, subscription products, store visitors, purchases, and conversion rates. You also adjust the reporting period, although the default setting covers the past 30 days.

Moreover, Sellfy connects Google Analytics with a Sellfy account. This gives business owners a more comprehensive view of the customer journey.

Shopify

Your specific plan determines Shopify’s Reporting and analytics features. Shopify provides a detailed analytics dashboard that allows you to monitor critical data like visitor count, traffic sources, best-selling products, top pages, and more. 

When integrated with Google Analytics, Shopify allows store owners to set up detailed workflows for various tasks, including recovering abandoned carts and retargeting customers. These comprehensive analytics and reporting tools facilitate data-driven decision-making, enhancing their store’s performance.

The Verdict

There is a tie between Shopify and Sellfy in terms of reporting & analytics. However, if merchants want a detailed report about sales, orders, traffic, referrals, and store growth, they should choose Shopify. Shopify offers 5 plans, from Starter to Plus, adapting to business requirements. 

Customer Support

Selling products online using any e-commerce store and marketing tools can be challenging. While there is a learning curve with any software, both Shopify and Sellfy strive to provide support when you need it most.

Sellfy

Business owners can contact the Sellfy Support Team via live chat, email or access the Sellfy Help Center for self-service support through articles and guides. 

This resource can help them understand various aspects, from SSL certificates to resolving download issues for their customers.

Shopify 

Shopify also offers comprehensive support features, including tools, online courses, blogs, videos, and webinars.

With 24/7 support, Shopify enables business owners to receive assistance through chat, phone, or email whenever required. This robust support system ensures merchants have access to essential resources and guidance to navigate the platform and resolve any problems.

The Verdict

Shopify is the winner regarding customer support. While Sellfy and Shopify share similarities in their customer service offerings, Shopify provides a slightly broader range of resources to assist merchants in expanding their online stores.

Shopify vs Sellfy: Which is Better? 

Shopify and Sellfy are outstanding e-commerce platforms enabling business owners to manage their online stores efficiently. Each platform boasts a range of remarkable features, aiding entrepreneurs to run their stores.

Sellfy is an excellent choice for starters in online selling who want to offer custom-made products or subscriptions. In contrast, Shopify is a perfect fit for those seeking a flexible platform for more complex e-commerce selling. Shopify can scale your business with greater ease.

Significantly, both Sellfy and Shopify can support print-on-demand services. However, Sellfy comes with this feature built-in, whereas Shopify provides it through plugins and integrations.

Shopify vs Sellfy: FAQs 

Bottom Line 

In summary, choosing between Shopify and Sellfy depends on your business needs. 

Shopify shines with its comprehensive payment options, extensive customization, and scalability. In contrast, Sellfy is an excellent fit for those just starting online selling or catering to a niche market.

Related Posts:

• Shopify vs Poshmark: Decoding the Best Platform for Sellers
• Alidropship vs Shopify – Which One is the Better Option?
• Shopify vs Etsy: Which is Better for an Online Store?