Home > Resources > Shopify vs Big Cartel: Navigating The Best Choice For Your Online Store

Shopify vs Big Cartel: Navigating The Best Choice For Your Online Store

Written and researched by experts at AvadaLearn more about our methodology

By Sam Nguyen

CEO Avada Commerce

Drive 20-40% of your revenue with Avada
avada email marketing

In this post, we’ll delve into the pivotal decision of Shopify vs Big Cartel, providing insights to help you choose the perfect platform for your online store.

Key Takeaways

  • Shopify is better than Big Cartel because it offers a more extensive feature set, scalability, and versatility. It caters to many businesses, from startups to enterprises, and provides robust SEO, marketing, and point-of-sale integration tools.
  • Big Cartel is better than Shopify for artists, makers, and creatives who want a simple, user-friendly platform to sell a limited range of products. Its free plan with no time limit makes it accessible for starting. Big Cartel’s focus on simplicity and ease of use is ideal for hobbyists and individuals looking to showcase their creative work.
  • Shopify is best for businesses of all sizes and industries, especially those with growth aspirations and needing advanced ecommerce functionalities. It provides scalability, a wide range of features, and comprehensive support.
  • Big Cartel is best for artists, makers, and smaller-scale businesses looking for a straightforward platform to showcase and sell their creative products.

Shopify vs Big Cartel: Quick Comparison

Shopify vs Big Cartel: Quick Comparison

The key difference between Shopify and Big Cartel lies in their target audience.

Shopify is a versatile, all-in-one ecommerce platform designed to cater to a wide range of businesses, from small startups to large enterprises. It offers an extensive feature set, unlimited product listings, and robust customization options, making it a strong choice for businesses looking to scale and grow over time. Shopify excels in SEO, marketing tools, point-of-sale integration, and customer support. However, this comes at a higher price point, making it more suitable for businesses with larger budgets.

On the other hand, Big Cartel is a niche platform primarily tailored for artists, makers, and creatives looking to set up an online store quickly and easily to sell a limited range of products. It offers a free plan, making it an accessible option for starting. However, its feature set is limited compared to Shopify, and it may not be suitable for businesses with ambitions for significant growth or those needing advanced ecommerce functionalities.

Shopify vs Big Cartel: Table Of Comparison

Criteria Shopify Big Cartel Winner
Ease of use Easy to use and more responsive. Easy to use. Shopify
Pricing 5 subscription plans to sell an unlimited number of products A free and 2 paid plans with a maximum of 500 products to sell Shopify
Web design
  • Over 150 customizable themes.
  • Fully responsive and optimized for speed
  • Drag and drop interface
  • Support for high-resolution images and videos
  • 16 mobile-optimized themes.
  • Customizable design
  • Image hosting and support for multiple product images.
  • Drag and drop for products listing only
Shopify
Ecommerce features
  • Over 105 external payment gateways.
  • Built-in payment gateway, Shopify Payments with no transaction fees
  • Unlimited product numbers.
  • Abandoned cart recovery on all plans.
  • Comprehensive shipping features with up to 88% discount
  • Dropshipping with various suppliers.
  • Robust inventory management, customer management features
  • Multiple sales channels
  • POS for in-person selling
  • Multiple payment options including Stripe and PayPal.
  • Maximum of 500 products.
  • Multiple sales channels
  • Inventory and shipment tracking
Shopify
Marketing Features
  • Robust SEO capabilities.
  • 10,000 emails per month for free.
  • Social media integration
  • Basic SEO tools.
  • Social media integration
Shopify
Security
  • Two-factor authentication (2FA) for added account protection.
  • Full PCI compliance.
  • SSL certificate for all stores.
  • SSL certificate for all stores.
  • Shopify
    Apps and add-on integration Over 8,000 apps integration. Less than 100 additional apps Shopify
    Help and support
    • 24/7 chat, email, and phone support.
    • Available in over 20 languages.
    • Support via email only from 8 am to 6 Shopify pm EST, Monday to Friday.
    • Only available in English.
    Shopify

    Big Cartel vs Shopify: Pros and Cons

    Big Cartel Shopify
    Pros
    • Easy to use
    • Cost-effective with a free plan available
    • Ready-made, customizable designs
    • No transaction fees
    • Mobile-friendly themes
    • Suitable for startups and businesses with few products
    • Unlimited products
    • Rich ecommerce features
    • Built-in SEO and marketing tools
    • Extensive integration and add-on options in its app store.
    • 24/7 Support
    • Scalability
    • Wide range of ready-made, customizable themes
    • Multi-channel selling
    • Easy to use
    Cons
    • Shallow depth in website features.
    • Outdated theme designs.
    • Constraints in customization options.
    • Higher price on subscription plans
    • Transaction fees.
    • There are some limitations for customization

    Big Cartel vs Shopify: Detailed Comparison

    In this detailed comparison, we’ll explore the key differences between Big Cartel and Shopify to help you make an informed decision for your online store.

    Pricing

    Shopify

    Shopify pricing

    Shopify offers 5 pricing plans, 4 of which allow merchants to create a full-function ecommerce store. The price starts at $39 to $2,000/ month, and the other package is Shopify Starter with $5 per month suitable for social network sellers. The prices can be reduced if you opt for annual billing, which offers a 25% discount.

    The platform also offers a 3-day free trial to explore if it fits your needs before making any commitment.

    Big Cartel

    Big Cartel pricing

    Big Cartel provides three subscription plans. The Gold plan comes with no monthly cost, while the Platinum and Diamond plans are priced at $9.99 and $19.99/ month, respectively.

    The Verdict

    If you need a more extensive online presence and scalability, Shopify is the winner. However, Big Cartel’s free plan may be the better option if you start with a limited budget and product range.

    Big Cartel’s free plan is a standout strength. However, it comes with significant limitations, including a cap on the number of products you can sell, which is 500 max.

    Shopify caters to businesses of all sizes with various costs based on the features of the plan. You can sell an unlimited number of products and choose to upgrade your plan as your business grows and requires more advanced features.

    User-Friendliness

    Shopify

    Shopify has built its reputation as one of the most user-friendly ecommerce platforms in the market. Designed to cater to both beginners and professionals, its intuitive drag-and-drop interface ensures that setting up a store is relatively straightforward. It involves four steps: adding your products, customizing your theme, creating a domain, and specifying tax and shipping details.

    The dashboard is cleanly designed with clearly marked sections for inventory management, sales analysis, customer information, and more. Plus, with its extensive library of themes, users can easily pick a design that suits their business without any design expertise.

    Big Cartel

    Big Cartel is tailored specifically for artists and makers, and this niche focus is evident in its simplistic and minimalist approach. For those who are just looking to set up a basic online store without delving deep into complex ecommerce functionalities, Big Cartel offers a straightforward experience.

    The dashboard is clean, making tasks like adding products, setting up prices, and managing orders pretty straightforward. While it doesn’t offer a vast range of features like Shopify, this stripped-down approach can appeal to its target audience.

    The Verdict

    Shopify’s user interface is slightly superior to Big Cartel. For those who want more expansive features with a gentle learning curve, Shopify is the go-to.

    Web Design

    Shopify

    Web Design shopify

    Shopify provides a broader range of web design options. Users can choose from over themes, with 1 available for free and others premium themes requiring purchases ranging from $140 to nearly $200. These paid themes offer extensive customization capabilities, allowing businesses to create unique online stores.

    All Shopify’s themes are optimized for mobile, ensuring that online stores look great and function seamlessly on all device types. They are also structured for conversions, with built-in design elements that cater to best ecommerce practices.

    For those who have a deeper understanding of web design, Shopify uses its own templating language called Liquid, which allows for advanced customizations.

    Big Cartel

    Web Design Big Cartel

    On the other hand, Big Cartel offers a selection of 16 mobile-optimized themes for designing websites, all of which are free.

    The available themes are clean and minimalistic, focusing on showcasing products in an aesthetic light. While it may not boast the extensive library that Shopify has, Big Cartel allows for custom HTML, CSS, and JavaScript.

    The Verdict

    Shopify takes the lead in web design. While Big Cartel offers simplicity and more free themes, Shopify outshines it with a broader selection of themes and greater customization freedom. Its themes are designed for a broad spectrum of industries and can accommodate businesses of all sizes. Big Cartel’s focus is only on simplicity and its niche appeal to artists and small brands.

    Ecommerce Features

    Payment gateways

    Payment gateways

    Shopify

    Shopify offers merchants multiple payment options to offer their customers. It includes a built-in payment gateway called ‘Shopify Payments,’ which is convenient for users as it requires less setup and doesn’t impose transaction fees on your sales. However, it’s important to note that Shopify Payments is only available in 23 countries. In addition to Shopify Payments, Shopify allows integration with over 105 external payment gateways. However, these third-party gateways may charge you some fees for using their service.

    Big Cartel

    Big Cartel doesn’t have its own payment gateway, it exclusively relies on integrations with external payment providers with two official payment methods: Stripe and PayPal. One notable advantage of Big Cartel is that it doesn’t charge transaction fees when accepting payments through your store. However, you will still incur credit card fees imposed by your chosen payment gateway. For example, in the US, Stripe typically charges around 2.9% plus $0.30 per transaction (fees may vary by location).

    The verdict

    Shopify outperforms Big Cartel regarding payment options and flexibility. Shopify undeniably has the upper hand with its vast array of choices, catering to a more extensive and diverse global market.

    Product numbers and product options

    Shopify

    Shopify allows you to sell an unlimited number of products on all of its plans. You can add tags, categorize items into categories, and create multiple product options and variants. While Shopify starts with up to 100 product variants, it truly shines with the help of third-party apps. Apps like Infinite Options by ShopPad enable Shopify merchants to significantly expand product options and variants, making it a robust choice for businesses with diverse catalogs.

    Big Cartel

    Big Cartel has specific limitations regarding the number of products you can list, even on its highest plan. It restricts you to a maximum of 500 products, which may not suffice for businesses with extensive inventories. While Big Cartel offers some flexibility in product customization, allowing up to 150 options per product listing, it struggles to compete with Shopify regarding scalability.

    The Verdict

    Regarding inventory size, Shopify stands out as the clear winner, making it a more suitable platform for merchants with more extensive product inventories. Big Cartel does offer useful features like ‘product variant groups’ that allow for creative combinations of product variables.

    Abandoned cart features

    Abandoned cart features

    Shopify

    Shopify excels in abandoned cart recovery which allows you to send automated emails to users who have added items to their cart but did not complete the checkout process. With Shopify’s abandoned cart feature, you can create these recovery emails using an intuitive email editor. Additionally, you have significant control over the conditions under which these emails are sent to your customers.

    Shopify provides “editable workflows” that enable you to establish if/then rules for sending these reminders. This level of customization ensures that you can tailor your abandoned cart recovery emails to your specific needs, making it a powerful tool for recapturing potentially lost sales.

    Big Cartel

    Big Cartel does not offer abandoned cart recovery functionality as a built-in feature. To implement abandoned cart recovery in a Big Cartel store, you must connect an email marketing app such as AWeber or Mailchimp. However, this approach involves additional configuration steps and may not provide the same level of seamless integration and customization as Shopify’s native feature.

    Point of Sale

    Shopify

    Shopify offers comprehensive Point of Sale (POS) capabilities, making it a versatile choice for online store owners who also need to process transactions in person at events, festivals, markets, or brick-and-mortar retail outlets. Shopify provides a dedicated POS app for payment processing, inventory tracking, and issuing receipts to customers. This app is tightly integrated with your online store’s backend, ensuring seamless data synchronization.

    With Shopify, you can access a wide range of first-party POS hardware. Shopify includes standard “Shopify POS Lite” features in all its plans. For more advanced POS capabilities, Shopify offers a “Shopify POS Pro” add-on priced at $89 per month per location for more advanced features.

    Big Cartel

    Big Cartel’s POS primarily relies on using a Stripe card reader for in-person transactions. While this may suffice for some basic POS needs, it lacks the comprehensive features and hardware integration that Shopify provides.

    The Verdict

    About Point of Sale (POS), Shopify is the clear winner. It offers a more extensive and tightly integrated solution for online store owners requiring POS capabilities and a wide range of POS hardware options. While Big Cartel offers some basic POS functionality through a Stripe card reader, it falls short of the robust and versatile POS system provided by Shopify.

    Shipping

    Shopify

    Shopify enables you to set your shipping rates and calculate shipping prices based on multiple factors. Shopify also offers built-in real-time shipping rates, allowing you to display live shipping prices from various postal companies to your customers. For users in specific countries (USA, Canada, France, Australia, Italy, Spain, and the UK), Shopify Shipping offers discounted rates from local postal services, offering savings as high as 88%, depending on the plan.

    As for dropshipping, Shopify seamlessly integrates with a myriad of apps like Printful, Dsers, etc. which allows merchants to easily import products from suppliers directly into their store and ship them straight to customers – no inventory or storage needed.

    Big Cartel

    Big Cartel does offer various shipping options and can integrate with third-party apps like Shipstation to enhance shipping capabilities. However, it needs some of the advanced features provided by Shopify, such as calculating shipping prices based on weight and offering built-in real-time shipping quotes.

    One area where Big Cartel does shine is in dropshipping. It offers dropshipping options via services like Printful and The Art of Where. These services allow you to upload artwork that can be printed onto products, with manufacturing and delivery handled by the companies involved. This feature caters well to its user base of artists and visual creatives.

    The Verdict

    However, Shopify’s shipping features are more comprehensive than Big Cartel’s. Its built-in features, integrations, and partner apps are designed to simplify and optimize both processes, making it a preferred choice for businesses that prioritize efficient shipping and dropshipping operations.

    Marketing Features

    Marketing Features

    SEO

    Shopify is the clear winner of Search Engine Optimization (SEO) capabilities. It offers a comprehensive suite of SEO tools and features that empower users to optimize their online stores effectively. With Shopify, you have complete control over critical SEO elements, including URL structure editing, redirects, and meta descriptions.

    This flexibility allows you to fine-tune your SEO strategy and enhance your website’s visibility in search results. Additionally, Shopify simplifies the process of meeting Google’s Core Web Vitals standards, ensuring your site’s speed and responsiveness align with search engine requirements.

    Big Cartel, while offering some SEO-friendly features like responsive design and valid HTML markup, falls short in key areas that are crucial for effective SEO. Notably, it needs robust URL structure editing capabilities and effective redirect management, which are essential for Google’s understanding of website content and indexing. Furthermore, the inability to edit meta descriptions presents a significant SEO disadvantage, as these descriptions can impact click-through rates and search rankings.

    Email marketing

    About email marketing, Shopify takes the lead over Big Cartel. Shopify offers a built-in email marketing solution called ‘Shopify Email,’ allowing users to host mailing lists and send e-newsletters without leaving the platform.

    Notably, Shopify Email allows users to send up to 10,000 emails per month for free, with a minimal cost of $1 USD per 1,000 additional emails sent (or $0.001 USD per additional email). While Shopify Email may be more basic than dedicated email marketing tools like AWeber and Mailchimp, it is user-friendly and cost-effective.

    In contrast, Big Cartel does not provide a built-in email marketing solution, requiring users to rely on third-party services like GetResponse or Mailchimp to handle their email marketing needs. This difference places Shopify ahead in terms of convenience and cost-effectiveness for users seeking integrated email marketing capabilities within their ecommerce platform.

    The Verdict

    Regarding marketing features, Shopify shines as the preferred platform, offering a comprehensive set of tools to elevate online stores’ visibility and engagement. In stark contrast, Big Cartel falls behind in critical marketing aspects. It lacks advanced SEO tools and does not provide a built-in email marketing solution, necessitating reliance on third-party services.

    Security

    Security

    Shopify

    Shopify prioritizes security with robust measures, including the option for users to enable Two-Factor Authentication (2FA) for enhanced account protection. Additionally, Shopify is fully PCI compliant, guaranteeing secure credit card transactions.

    Big Cartel

    On the other hand, Big Cartel emphasizes platform security but lacks support for Two-Factor Authentication (2FA). While payments are processed through third-party gateways, Big Cartel falls short in PCI compliance, with users retaining potential liability.

    The Verdict

    About security, Shopify emerges as the superior choice. It offers Two-Factor Authentication (2FA) for added account protection and maintains full PCI compliance, ensuring secure credit card transactions. While Big Cartel prioritizes security, Shopify’s comprehensive security measures make it the winner, providing users with a safer ecommerce environment.

    Apps and Add-ons Integration

    Apps and Add-ons Integration

    Shopify

    Shopify’s app store is a robust marketplace with an impressive selection of over 8,000 apps, offering solutions for virtually every aspect of running an online store. These apps cover various functionalities, including accounting, customer relationship management (CRM), email marketing, and social media integration. Shopify’s app store is well-organized, making it user-friendly and allowing store owners to easily find and select the right apps to enhance their e-commerce operations.

    Big Cartel

    Big Cartel, while more limited in its native app offerings with just 27 available, compensates by integrating with Zapier. This connection opens the door to approximately 5,000 additional apps, extending functionality options for users. However, it’s important to note that utilizing Zapier often incurs additional costs, and not all integrations are free or unlimited.

    The Verdict

    About apps and add-ons integration, Shopify secures a clear victory due to its extensive app store and user-friendly interface. With over 8,000 readily available apps catering to various needs, Shopify provides users a comprehensive ecosystem for enhancing their online stores. While Big Cartel offers integration with Zapier, Shopify’s vast selection and convenience make it the superior choice for expanding your store’s feature set and capabilities.

    Help and Support

    Shopify

    Shopify offers a comprehensive set of support options. They provide chat, email, and phone support, accessible 24/7. The support materials are available in over 20 languages, making it more inclusive for international users.

    However, it’s important to note that Shopify encourages users to search for answers in their help site before providing direct contact details for support. This additional step can be a bit cumbersome for users seeking immediate assistance.

    The quality of Shopify’s support may also vary depending on whether you’re inquiring about Shopify-built apps or templates versus third-party ones. In-house support for Shopify’s products tends to be more comprehensive, while support for third-party products relies on the developers of those products.

    Big Cartel

    Big Cartel provides a decent support center with various helpful articles covering various aspects of running an online store on their platform. These articles are well-written and informative.

    However, the availability of direct customer support from real people is limited. Big Cartel only has 12 support staff, and they are available Monday to Friday from 8 a.m. to 6 p.m. EST. The primary support channel is via email, with no live chat or phone support.

    Additionally, Big Cartel’s customer support is offered exclusively in English, which may be a limitation for non-English-speaking users.

    The Verdict

    About help and support, Shopify offers a more extensive and accessible support system compared to Big Cartel. Shopify provides round-the-clock assistance, multiple contact options, and support in various languages, making it a more user-friendly choice for those who value customer support.

    Bottom Line

    Shopify is the winner in the battle of Shopify vs Big Cartel, offering a robust and versatile ecommerce platform suitable for businesses of all sizes. Its extensive feature set, scalability, and superior customization options make it a top choice for those looking to build a successful online store. While Big Cartel’s simplicity and budget-friendly options cater to smaller ventures and artists, Shopify’s comprehensive offering and exceptional support make it the winner for ecommerce entrepreneurs.

    FAQs

    Big Cartel refrains from imposing transaction fees; however, credit card fees will be incurred through your chosen payment processor, Stripe or PayPal. Similarly, Shopify can bypass transaction fees by utilizing its native Shopify Payments processor. Otherwise, if opting for a third-party payment gateway, Shopify levies a transaction fee ranging from 0.5% to 2.0%, contingent on your selected plan.

    Connecting Big Cartel and Shopify is a breeze with Zapier. This powerful tool enables automatic data transfer between Big Cartel and Shopify without coding. With support for over 5,000 apps, the integration possibilities are limitless.

    Shopify does charge transaction fees on each sale made through its platform, in addition to any fees charged by your chosen payment gateway. Big Cartel, on the other hand, does not charge transaction fees but may have credit card processing fees through its payment gateways.

    Related Posts:


    Sam Nguyen is the CEO and founder of Avada Commerce, an e-commerce solution provider headquartered in Singapore. He is an expert on the Shopify e-commerce platform for online stores and retail point-of-sale systems. Sam loves talking about e-commerce and he aims to help over a million online businesses grow and thrive.